I Love Thrift Stores - thrift store directory for Canada and the USA
New York thrift guide

Thrift stores in New York City, NY

Explore nonprofit thrift, vintage and resale across Manhattan and Brooklyn, including a deeper set of neighbourhood stops that work well by subway or on foot.

14 thrift stores to explore

Use the filters to narrow the hunt, then open any store that catches your eye for more details.

0 of 14 visitedYour Thrift Passport progress in New York City.
Open passport
Want to turn this into a thrift day?Build a 2-hour, half-day or full-day route through New York City.
Plan a New York City thrift trip
Closed now

City Opera Thrift Shop

513 W 26th St, New York, NY 10001

Nonprofit thrift shop

ClothingHousewaresFurnitureCollectibles
Checked recently Last checked September 2026
Store details
Closed now

HEE-space Thrift Shop

461 Rogers Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225

Thrift store

ClothingHousewaresAccessories
Checked recently Last checked September 2026
Store details
Hours to verify

Vintage Thrift Shop

286 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10010

Nonprofit thrift shop

VintageClothingHousewaresFurniture
Checked recently Last checked September 2026
Store details

Thrifting in New York City

New York City has more secondhand shopping than anyone could reasonably fit into one thrift day. Manhattan and Brooklyn alone offer Housing Works shops, independent vintage, nonprofit thrift and buy-sell-trade stores, so it is worth choosing a neighbourhood before you head out.

Walking and transit make it practical to combine nearby stores. Housing Works locations on the Upper East Side, Upper West Side, Chelsea, Gramercy and the West Village can be treated as neighbourhood anchors, while Brooklyn Heights and Park Slope make separate Brooklyn clusters.

New York resale prices vary enormously. A curated vintage store and a nonprofit thrift shop may both sell used clothing, but they are different shopping experiences. We label the store type so you know which kind of hunt you're choosing.

Spot something that changed?

Thrift stores move, hours change and donation rules get updated. Send us a quick note and we'll take another look.

Update a store →